Water Ionizers and reviews from Alkaline Water Plus

Additional Information

Site Information

 Loading... Please wait...

Blog

The New Athena-H2 Water Ionizer Compared With the Enagic, Tyent, Smart 7P, Vesta and Jupiter Athena

Posted by Alkaline Water Plus on

The New Athena Water Ionizer Compared With the Original Jupiter Athena, Smart 7P, Vesta GL, Enagic and Tyent Water Ionizers

The brand new Athena-H2 water ionizer is terrific. This 36 minute video shows how it compares with 6 top water ionizers at every level of ionized water. The ionizers tested in this video were: the Athena H2, the original Jupiter Classic Athena water ionizer, the Nexus Smart 7P, Vesta GL, Enagic SD501, and Tyent water ionizers. If you are trying to buy a water ionizer and want to compare the best water ionizers, you should definitely watch the video, and also look at the details, commentaries and charts throughout this post. 

Water Ionizer Charts, Comparisons & Understanding the Results

I've put each water ionizer's results into a chart and section of its own, and included the pH and ORP (oxidation reduction potential) at each alkaline ionized water drinking level for that water ionizer. In addition I have analyzed the results. 

Included in my analysis is how efficiently each water ionizer is able to ionize water (in other words, produce high levels of antioxidants) at each level. There is actually a mathematical formula used to measure that. Scientists working to develop better water ionizers use this formula as an easy way to test for the amount of molecular hydrogen, H2-antioxidants, produced at each level for their water ionizers. This is called finding the relative Hydrogen (or how much ORP per unit of pH) for each level. Since Hydrogen increases as the pH increases, the formula provides a way to look at the results and determine the amount of Hydrogen per unit of raised pH. More information about the formula can be found at the end of this post. Since Hydrogen-antioxidants are basically electrons, measured in negative numbers, the "best", most efficient ionization would produce a lower, or more negative, number. 

The following chart illustrates this. To the right of the chart, where the numbers are the most negative, you will find your most efficient results. To the left, where the numbers are positive you will find the average to poor results. To help you realize instantly which results are best, I have circled the best, most outstanding, results in blue.

Water Ionizer Comparisons - Quality & Efficiency of Ionization

The New Athena-H2 Water Ionizer

This water ionizer did an outstanding job. With 5 levels of alkaline ionized water to test, the ORP (antioxidant) results at every level were outstanding. The ionizer shows the ability to get a great range of alkaline pH with my source water, from 8 to 11.6. And the ionizer has the most advanced, state-of-the-art, electronics, making it run cooler. Predictably this water ionizer will last longer than most of its predecessors.

Why does the Athena H2 perform so well compared to all of the other water ionizers? I think there are many reasons for the outstanding performance of the Athena H2 water ionizer, but because a lot of the design is proprietary and a trade secret I can only tell you that within the electronic structure the power switches from alternating current to direct current, which is one of the ways the greater amounts of antioxidants is achieved.

Another interesting performance explanation is that there are just the right size and number of electrodes in the Athena-H2. When manufacturers put too few or even too many electrodes into a water ionizer it can reduce the performance. My testing shows that the Athena H2 has just the right number/size of electrodes to get the maximum efficiency and results at all levels.

Testing the Athena H-2 Water Ionizer

Jupiter Athena Water Ionizer (Original)

The original Jupiter Athena water ionizer, with 4 levels of alkaline ionized water, also had great results at every level. The Athena has the capacity to be programmed with an easy power-boosting function, which I demonstrated in the video. I had the booster set to the highest levels, but it is possible to set it lower to accommodate those who would want to drink at lower pH-levels. The Jupiter Athena water ionizer is the one that I have been using with my family for many years.

Jupiter Athena Water Ionizer Testing

The Nexus Smart 7P Water Ionizer

The Nexus Smart 7P also did great at every level. 

Nexus Smart 7P Water Ionizer Testing

The Vesta GL Water Ionizer

The Vesta GL is a very strong water ionizer with a fast flow-rate. The lower two levels were programmed lightly, but have the capability to be programmed higher. The top two levels with the stronger program settings did an outstanding job, especially considering the faster flow-rate.

Vesta GL Water Ionizer Test Results

The Enagic SD501 Water Ionizer (Kangen Water)

The Enagic water ionizer did fine, but not as fine as the other water ionizers. I've seen it do better than this, so I'm guessing I need to do a deep-cleaning. I've never seen it do as well as the top three machines above though.

The Tyent Water Ionizer

The Tyent 7-plate water ionizer typically performs better than the newer Tyent machines. The reason for this is explained in this article: 

WHY YOU SHOULD NOT BUY A 9, 11 OR 13-PLATE WATER IONIZER

This Tyent water ionizer actually had excellent results for the most part, but not as excellent as the top four water ionizers, above. 

Tyent Water Ionizer Testing

Relative Hydrogen Formula

Relative Hydrogen means "how much Hydrogen-Antioxidant potential is within a given sample relative to the pH of the sample". When you want to determine which water ionizer is working best at a particular pH-level for your source water, determining the relative Hydrogen is the easiest and most reliable way to find that out. Water ionization efficiency can be found scientifically when you look at its relative Hydrogen. Using the Relative Hydrogen formula to compare water ionizers is the most scientific and accurate way to do it.

The easiest way to compare the relative Hydrogen of two samples of ionized water is when both samples have the same pH-levels. In this case, the one with the higher ORP would clearly be the best.

When you have samples you're trying to compare, but their pH levels are different, it's still possible to determine which is "best" by applying a mathematical formula. Here is the formula for relative Hydrogen. 

RH = (ORP / 30) + (2 * pH): 

  1. First you take the ORP and divide it by 30. If the ORP is negative, then the answer will be negative.
  2. Next you take the pH of the sample and multiply it by two.
  3. Finally you add the two numbers together. Usually the first number is negative, so in essence you'd then subtract that from the other number.

Using this formula I derived the rH for every sample tested in the water ionizer comparisons, above. I plotted the results on a number line and clearly marked sections for you, so you can easily see a visual of how good a result is.

Something I always keep in mind when doing water ionizer comparisons is that one set of results is just one set. There are so many variables in testing and comparing water ionizers, that even minor changes in your source water or how cleaned & conditioned the meters are can make a big difference.

The reason I like to test a lot of water ionizers against each other all at the same time is to get a more true picture by eliminating as many variables as possible.

Another thing is that the results are grouped in the number-line, above, for a reason. This is to show you that minute variations, such as the difference between an rH of -4.07 and -5 are fairly insignificant. Both of those rH scores are too close to each other to really call. They are both in the category of the "absolute best".

Hopefully I didn't get too technical for you. I encourage you to visit my Water Ionizer Comparisons page to see all of the features of the 25 most popular water ionizers compared in one huge scrolling chart. It also gives great explanations of the various water ionizer features that you will definitely want to know if you're searching for the best water ionizer for you.

View Comments


One of the Very Best Water Ionizers: Vesta

One of the best water ionizers I’ve ever tested is the Vesta! I get excited when I see the great pH and ORP results that the Vesta GL water ionizer can easily and quickly deliver. Here’s some recent testing I did. The favorite thing I love about the Vesta water ionizer is the fact that it will [...]

Read More »


Vesta Water Ionizer Review

The new Vesta GL water ionizer is the best water ionizer of 2012, and in many ways I think it’s the best I’ve ever seen.Features of the Vesta GL water ionizer: The Vesta GL water ionizer has been approved as a medical device in Korea (Korea FDA No.: 3277).The Vesta’s AutoAdjust™ feature is the best plate-cleaning design I’ve [...]

Read More »


Vesta Water Ionizer verses Enagic: Which Water Ionizer is Better at the Fastest Flow Rate?

I have been testing and comparing the new Vesta water ionizer, and I am very impressed with it. The video comparison here in this blog post is the most impressive one so far. Both the Vesta water ionizer and the Enagic Kangen Water SD 501 alkaline water machine will perform water ionization at a much faster flow [...]

Read More »


The New Vesta Water Ionizer: Compared with Enagic, Jupiter & Tyent

I was pretty impressed when I saw the literature on the new water ionizer that Emco Tech [big-name manufacturer] has come out with. You can see all the details on the  Vesta page, but I will highlight some of the features here along with showing how the Vesta water ionizer compares with the Enagic SD 501 Kangen Water [...]

Read More »


Cathleen Lograsso

Cathleen LoGrasso

Cathleen was a teacher/principal for 24 years and has been drinking ionized water for about 25 years. She created Alkaline Water Plus to educate people about the benefits of ionized water.

"The very best thing I have ever purchased is a WATER IONIZER!" Cathleen LoGrasso, Owner/CEO Alkaline Water Plus

Subscribe by Email

Get every post sent to your email address.

Fill out my online form.

Archives

Search

Search results are always reported with two tabs: "Products" first and "News & Information" second.Look for these tabs.